Wednesday, June 17, 2020

All We All Problematic?

I've been thinking a lot about John Scalzi's recent post about generations and discrimination. One of the points of his post is that each generation has to come to terms with their biases, and their targets may differ with each generation. Just as we deplore the sexism and racism of earlier generations, in time, other generations may find their own reasons to think we're unenlightened about subjects they value. Is it ever going to be possible to free ourselves from all biases?

Unfortunately, probably not, unless human nature changes dramatically. Here are a few factors discussed in Blueprint: The Evolutionary Origins of a Good Society. The more bonded we are to our in-group, the more we distrust outsiders. Humans require some leadership, but too much hierarchy or too much inequality leads to instability. According to Scientific American, wealth tends to become concentrated in the hands of a few over time. The more wealth you have, the easier it is to rig the scales in your favor--and perhaps even convince others that this situation is natural. We're also prone to implicit bias, though there are ways to overcome it.So if we all have biases, does this mean we're always going to have to deal with systemic discrimination?

I think this is really going to depend on how much empathy and open-mindedness we have. Open-mindedness is part of an individual's personality, but empathy can be developed, especially by reading fiction. We need to view ourselves as belonging to different groups and work to establish connections between them. We also have to learn about the ways we distort critical thinking to support our biases instead of viewing them objectively. This work may never be finished, but each of us is obliged to contribute. We become problematic when we fail to show empathy to others or change our minds when we're shown new evidence.

What do you think is the best way to tackle discrimination? Feel free to share your thoughts in the comments.

2 comments:

Alex J. Cavanaugh said...

I think I'll just go with what our pastor said - if we all had and showed the same love God has for us, would that issue even exist?

emaginette said...

I'm not sure it this reflects your post, but here I go. A long while back I lived in Vancouver and my workmate, and friend was ranting about her neighbors. I asked her if she said the same things in front of her children.

She admitted she did. I asked her what her children will think of POC now that they had heard her views. She shut up. She checked-in with her three girls. One, the oldest, still hates POC, and my friend holds herself completely responsible.

Sometimes we don't know what we do to others. :-)

Anna from elements of emaginette

Site Meter